Carlton County Watch is an independent, citizen-driven online newspaper committed to exposing government waste, corruption, and incompetence across Carlton County, Minnesota. Our mission is to shine a bright and unrelenting light on local institutions and officials who betray the public trust. Through investigative reporting, public records research, and fearless truth-telling, we empower residents to hold their leaders accountable, demand transparency, and reclaim their community. We serve no special interests — only the public interest.
Minnesota's Judiciary: Extraordinary Power, Minimal Qualification Requirements, and Almost No Electoral Competition
Who is judging Minnesota's judges? Minnesota entrusts extraordinary power to its judiciary, yet its Constitution requires little more than that judges be "learned in the law." With nearly 98% of judicial races featuring unopposed incumbents in 2026, where is the meaningful accountability? Carlton County Watch examines judicial qualifications, appointments, and elections — and calls on the Minnesota Legislature to consider sweeping reforms, including 20 years of legal experience, advanced academic qualifications, transparent performance records, and a lifetime two-term limit. Those entrusted with protecting our constitutional rights should be held to rigorous, publicly verifiable standards.
Decency Is Not a Political Party: A Response to the Pine Knot's Election Editorial
Decency for Democrats, condemnation for Republicans? In its latest editorial, the Pine Knot News celebrates Democratic election victories as a triumph of moral virtue while condemning President Trump and his supporters. But where is that same moral outrage over Bill Clinton's documented misconduct or the massive government fraud that unfolded under Minnesota's Democratic executive leadership? Carlton County Watch examines the Pine Knot's selective moral framing, challenges its apparent double standard, and asks a simple question: Since when did political affiliation determine who is decent?
"Remove Him So He’s Not Recording": Body-Camera Footage Raises Questions About Dirty Carlton County Deputies’ Handling of Assault Arrest
Dirty Cops in Carlton County? When Protecting an Assault Suspect Appears More Important Than Protecting the First Amendment. On October 17, 2024, Carlton County Sheriff's Sgt. Justin Frykman and Deputy James Stracek were preparing to arrest Leonard Simich for assault. But when Simich expressed concern that his victim might record the arrest and publish it on social media, the deputies' response took a troubling turn. Newly released body-camera footage captures discussions that raise serious questions about whether the deputies coordinated an effort to distract the victim and conceal the arrest from public view. Even after acknowledging the citizen's right to record police activity, did these deputies place an assault suspect's desire to avoid public embarrassment above transparency and constitutional protections? Watch the footage. Hear the conversation. Judge the evidence for yourself.
Punched in the Face. Denied Justice. Then Prosecuted: Questions Carlton County Must Answer.
Carlton County Assistant Attorney Demonte Noble acknowledged in open court that M, the victim of a violent assault, was punched or in the face. Yet the assault charges against Leonard Simich were dismissed “in the interests of justice,” while M, the man who reported being assaulted, continues to face criminal prosecution. Adding to the controversy, the Carlton County prosecutor who signed Simich's dismissal, Amy Voss, works for the law firm associated with his defense. How did the assault victim become the defendant, and whose interests did Carlton County's pursuit of justice actually serve? Carlton County Watch examines the court records, troubling questions about prosecutorial discretion, and the principle of equal justice under the law. Carlton County Watch stands with M and we hope you will too.
Carlton County Commissioners’ Compensation: Salaries, Benefits, Per Diems — and an Incomplete Public Accounting
What does it really cost Carlton County taxpayers to compensate their elected commissioners? Beyond annual salaries, commissioners may receive additional per diem payments, taxpayer-funded health insurance, retirement contributions, life insurance, and other benefits. County records reveal that per diem spending had already exceeded its entire 2026 budget by August — while questions about individual payments and reimbursements remain unanswered. Carlton County Watch examines the true cost of elected office and asks a fundamental question: Has public service become a taxpayer-funded career with benefits?
The Man Who Was Punched In The Face — and Then Prosecuted
After a violent assault by Leonard Simich in Carlton County, the victim of the assault now faces criminal charges involving his criticism of sheriff's deputies and his calls to 911, while the prosecution of his alleged assailant was dismissed. As a November 2 jury trial approaches, Carlton County Watch examines the evidence, prosecutorial decisions, and a fundamental constitutional question: When does criticizing law enforcement become a crime?
Carlton County Sheriff's Office Complaint Records: What the First Production Reveals — and What Remains Unanswered
Carlton County Sheriff's Office records identify nine complaints involving eight deputies and investigators between January 2024 and March 2026. But the initial production leaves important questions about complaint tracking, oversight, missing reporting periods, and access to public personnel data. Carlton County Watch examines what the records establish — and what the County has yet to explain.
Who Is Jeffrey Boucher? Why does his County Attorney’s Office Photo Look Like It’s 10 Years Old?A Closer Look at Carlton County's Unopposed County Attorney Candidate
Jeffrey Boucher is running unopposed for Carlton County Attorney in November 2026. From his failed 2024 nomination for a Minnesota judgeship to unanswered questions about his office's workload and performance, Carlton County Watch examines the public record and the information residents still need to evaluate their county's chief prosecutor.
Carlton County's 2025 Data Breach: 3,502 People, Compromised Email Mailbox — and Questions Still Unanswered
In early 2025, a hacker downloaded the contents of a Carlton County HHS employee's mailbox, affecting 3,502 people. Months later, the County's longtime IT director was terminated following an attorney-client closed session. Meanwhile, auditors trace a significant computer-risk-management deficiency back to 2006. Early evidence suggests that the hack was extensive to include both the County Attoney’s Office and the County Sheriff’s Office. Carlton County Watch examines what we know — and the questions the County still needs to answer.
The Red Zone Is Gone. The Language Remains. What Is Carlton County Really Planning for County Road 4?
Carlton County Commissioner Susan Zmyslony confirms that the controversial Regional Commercial designation at I-35 and County Road 4 near Mahtowa has been removed from the County's preliminary 2050 land-use map following public feedback. But the September 29 planning memorandum still identifies County Road 4 as a corridor for Regional Commercial development. Carlton County Watch examines what changed, what remains, and why the public deserves a clear explanation.
Before You Ask for Our Vote, Answer Two Questions
Before candidates ask Carlton County voters for their support in 2026, we think they should answer two straightforward questions: Will you support reasonable term limits? And can you show taxpayers what your office would look like with a 25% smaller budget? Forget the slogans about fiscal responsibility and accountability. Show us the numbers. Show us the cuts. Show us the plan. Then let voters decide whether the answers are good enough.
Why Is the Default Always More?
Carlton County keeps asking taxpayers for more. But when does government ever ask itself to spend less? As the County Attorney’s budget climbs (> 10%), Carlton County Watch examines the missing question in the annual budget debate: what would happen if county government were required to cut costs instead of automatically increasing them?
3.9% Is Now on the Record
Carlton County commissioners say the proposed 9.02% levy increase needs to come down — and Commissioner Dan Reed says the County must “grow somehow.” But what does economic growth actually look like in Carlton County? Just weeks after unanimously approving a one-year pause on data-center development, the Board now faces a larger question: if expanding the tax base is part of the answer to rising property taxes, what industries and investments is the County prepared to welcome? Carlton County Watch looks beyond the slogans and asks where the economic-development strategy is.
Minnesota’s $2.4 Billion School Fund: What Voters Are Actually Being Asked to Change
This November, Minnesotans will vote on a constitutional amendment involving one of the state's largest — and least understood — public assets: the approximately $2.4 billion Minnesota Permanent School Fund.
Created from lands granted for the support of public schools, the fund has grown for generations through timber, mineral royalties, land transactions and investment returns. Today, its principal is constitutionally protected as “perpetual and inviolate forever,” while investment income helps support every public school district and charter school in Minnesota.
The 2026 amendment would change that framework. If approved, Minnesota would move toward a modern endowment model that distributes 4.5% of the fund's three-year average value, while requiring the fund's purchasing power to be preserved for future generations.
So what exactly is the Permanent School Fund? Where did its billions of dollars come from? How is the money used today? And what are Minnesotans gaining — and changing — under the proposed amendment?
Carlton County Watch takes a closer look at the history, money and constitutional language behind one of the most consequential questions on Minnesota's 2026 ballot.
Carlton County Approved $327,900 for Barnum Housing. The Records Still Leave Key Affordability Questions Unanswered
Carlton County approved $327,900 in State Affordable Housing Aid for a five-home development in Barnum and told commissioners that the homes would carry an 80% income restriction. But newly released County records still leave some of the most important questions unanswered: Who qualifies to buy the homes? What will they cost? Must buyers occupy them? Can they later be rented or quickly resold? And what document actually makes the affordability requirement enforceable?
Carlton County Watch reviewed the latest production and found an extensive paper trail surrounding the project — but the mechanics behind the promised affordability protections remain unclear. We are now seeking the missing agreements, eligibility rules, resale restrictions, recapture provisions and other records that should show exactly how the public's investment will be protected.
Carlton County Eyes 9.02% Property-Tax Levy Increase for 2027
Carlton County is considering a 9.02% property-tax levy increase for 2027 — an additional $3.21 million over the 2026 levy. Commissioners will discuss the preliminary budget during a special 4:00 PM meeting today, with the preliminary levy scheduled to be set September 28. Carlton County Watch takes a first look at where the money is going and the questions taxpayers should be asking.
Sheriff’s Policy Says Complaints Should Be Logged and Audited. What Do the Records Show?
The Carlton County Sheriff’s current policy says personnel complaints and inquiries should be documented in a tracking log — and that the log should undergo an annual audit. Following earlier reporting on the Michael Soderstrom matter, public-data requests are now seeking the complaint logs, historical policies, audit reports, and records of outside or criminal-investigation referrals. With Sheriff Kelly Lake’s retirement approaching, Carlton County Watch is asking a simple question about the accountability system the next sheriff will inherit: What do the records show?
No Record of Criminal Review: Sheriff Lake’s Response Raises New Questions About the 2018 Soderstrom Incident
Eight years after former Carlton County Deputy Mike Soderstrom was disciplined following a threatening off-duty confrontation at the Third Base Bar, a major question remains unanswered: Was his conduct ever reviewed as potential criminal conduct at all?
Carlton County Watch asked Sheriff Kelly Lake for records documenting any criminal investigation, charging review, prosecutorial referral, declination, or decision not to pursue criminal review. Lake’s September 4 response was striking: her office found “no data responsive” to the request. Lake is retiring at the end of her term, leaving Carlton County voters to select a new sheriff.
The records do not establish a cover-up or prove that Soderstrom committed a crime. But they raise a fundamental accountability question: When potentially criminal conduct is alleged against one of law enforcement’s own, who makes sure the allegation receives the same scrutiny that would apply to everyone else?
Still Affordable to Whom? Barnum's Answers Raise New Questions
Barnum has now confirmed that Tracts 2 and 5 were transferred to Ideal Homes on August 25, 2026. The City says the project will cost Barnum “ZERO,” yet the land itself was the City’s contribution — and Barnum says it will impose no liens or affordability rules beyond ordinary zoning. The land has changed hands. The bigger question now is whether the public subsidy will remain affordable housing — or eventually become private gain.
Barnum Promised Answers. A Month Later, It Sent a Form.
Barnum promised answers about its five-home housing development and transfer of public land to Ideal Homes. A month later, the public is still waiting. Instead of answering questions about land value, affordability, subsidies, and taxpayer protections, the City sent Carlton County Watch a data-request form — along with a policy dated 2011. The paperwork arrived. The answers did not.